Skip to content
London Fruit Insight

If the Blacksmith Has a Million Haters, Then I Am Among Them.

Upon learning the news about Clint in Stardew Valley had been announced as a new marriage candidates in the forthcoming 1.7 update, I exclaimed with disbelief, “Him?!” The news consumed me for the rest of the evening — if Clint has a legion of critics (which he certainly does), I am one of them; were he to have no enemies, I have left the world of the living. Yet, with some reflection, I now realize that maybe that’s exactly the point — there is no character in greater need of a second chance than Clint.

The Source of the Ire

Pelican Town's blacksmith has drawn significant criticism over the years, largely due to his fixation on Emily, another marriage candidate. In one of his early cutscenes, he asks the player about how to talk to women, then behaves incredibly awkwardly around Emily, as she serves him in the saloon, then laments to the player that he’s “finished.” He often appears pessimistic, desperate, and somewhat unsettling — in many ways, he embodies a classic “nice guy” who gets angry at the smallest hint of rejection.

A Widespread Reaction

My reaction to this part of the 1.7 update was far from unique. Players have voiced a host of grievances, sadness about who should've been chosen instead, and countless memes since the news dropped. One social media user remarked, “Picture finishing the worst shift of your life and learning Clint is now a marriable character in Stardew Valley.”

A Glimmer of Hope

Nevertheless, some discussion about this offers a brighter perspective and — as much as I hate to admit it — makes a few good points. Several players have compared the prospect of reforming Clint to that of Haley. She is extremely mean when you first meet her, but softens over time as you befriend her, a journey some have called “power-leveling Haley so she sucks less as a person.” Clint possesses much that same potential, but with a crucial distinction: he makes many gamers the ick.

Image: ConcernedApe

The Uneasy Feeling

For me, Haley’s initial unpleasantness more palatable than Clint’s one-sided obsession with a woman who isn't interested, and many other players appear to share the same. It’s hard to place exactly precisely why — maybe it's simply a situation many fans can relate to, giving them a more visceral reaction to Clint. This ick factor inherent to Clint undeniably presents an extra wrinkle in him being seen as an desirable marriage candidate, but that might be just another reason the character is in dire need of a turnaround.

A Trace of Understanding

It must be said that, as many times as I’ve complained about Clint needing to change his ways, he does inspire a degree of sympathy. Maybe not during the infamous scene in the bushes, but in general, he comes across as a sad, lonely man. A fan wrote, “He is a man yearning for someone to reciprocate his feelings, and this is what being romanceable offers him.”

A Role for Redemption

The blacksmith's upcoming relationship storyline may not be for all types of Stardew Valley player, but it does have its place. As dubious as I am that I could ever consider him as spouse material, ConcernedApe is a skilled storyteller known for giving depth to every character in Pelican Town. Just as with previous expansions, the new version seems to be a sizable content drop crafted with care at its heart, and his character arc is unlikely to be handled carelessly. Perhaps with Clint’s new chance at love, players can at last set aside their disdain for Clint and place it where it truly belongs — toward Pierre.

By

Alexander Davis

Freelance food writer with a passion for fruit markets and sustainable agriculture.

London Fruit Insight

Type to search articles.